Short answer: Colossians 2:16–17 tells believers not to let anyone judge them regarding eating, drinking, festivals, new moons, or a Sabbath day, because those things were a shadow of what was coming and the body belongs to Christ. The verse does not command believers to abandon such days, and it does not command them to keep them. It forbids making any observance a test of standing before God. So keeping a Sunday sabbath is neither a sin nor a law; the question sits under Christ's lordship rather than under human judgment.
The setting of Colossians 2:16-17: a command against judgment grounded in the cross
Colossians is a letter, not a sermon transcript or a rulebook, and Paul writes it to a congregation he did not plant, in a city where competing religious claims were pressing in on the church. The believers there were a mixed group, Jewish and Gentile, and some teachers were pushing them to treat disputed observances as the measure of spiritual maturity. That is the pressure behind this paragraph. Paul is not answering a question about which day is correct in the abstract. He is pastoring people being graded by others over food, drink, festivals, new moons and Sabbaths.
The literary shape matters. Verses 14 and 15 come first and lay the ground: the record of ordinances against us has been wiped out, taken away, and nailed to the cross, and the powers have been stripped and publicly triumphed over. Verse 16 then draws a conclusion from that work, tying the command not to let anyone judge you directly to what happened at the cross. The order is deliberate. Grace and finished work come first, and the instruction about judging follows. The paragraph is not a bare rule about calendars but an argument from Christ's sufficiency.
Verses 18 and 19 turn to a different error, self-abasement and angel worship, and warn that such religion does not hold firmly to the Head. Read together, the whole paragraph targets religious add-ons, whether ascetic rules or calendar rules, that get treated as markers of maturity. Notice too that the command cuts in both directions. It forbids others from judging the readers, and it leaves no room for the readers to despise those whose consciences differ. The text is a guard against contempt, not a license for it.
The occasion is a church under pressure to measure itself by observances, and Paul answers that pressure by pointing back to the cross before he says a word about days. That sequence shapes everything that follows in this passage.
What the words of Colossians 2:16-17 actually say
Paul begins with a courtroom word. To judge, here, is to hand down a verdict on someone else's standing before God. The list that follows runs from the table to the calendar: eating and drinking, then a feast day, a new moon, a Sabbath day. Notice that the Sabbath is named last and alongside the other two, not lifted out as the one item that still binds. Paul is not ranking the days or telling anyone which one to keep. He is addressing the habit of passing verdicts on another believer's practice. The verse forbids the verdict, not the observance.
Then comes the reason: these things are a shadow of what is coming. A shadow is real. It is cast by something solid, and it points toward it. But no one mistakes the shadow for the person. Paul is not sneering at the feast days or the Sabbath, which God himself gave to his people. He is saying they were provisional pointers, and the pointer has done its work. The closing line settles the direction of the argument: the body, the substance the shadow pointed to, belongs to Christ. The observance was never the point. Christ is the point, and he is not a shadow.
So what do these terms decide? Not which day anyone must keep, but who decides. The text gives no command to move the Sabbath to Sunday, and it gives no command to keep Saturday either. What it forbids is the courtroom, and it forbids it in both directions. A believer who keeps Saturday out of conscience is not to be put on trial by a Sunday keeper, and a Sunday keeper is not to be held in contempt by a Saturday keeper. The shadow has given way to the body, and the body is Christ's. That is where the passage leaves the question of days: with him, and with a warning against judging one another.
What Colossians 2:16-17 actually forbids
Start with the word that opens verse 16: therefore. The command not to judge rests on what God has already done in verses 14 and 15. The record of ordinances that stood against us has been wiped out, taken away, and nailed to the cross. The principalities and powers have been stripped and publicly triumphed over. So when Paul says no one may judge you in eating, drinking, a feast day, a new moon, or a Sabbath day, he is not launching a new rule about calendars. He is drawing a conclusion from the cross. The courtroom has been closed because the debt was paid there.
Then look at the reason given in verse 17. These observances are a shadow of the things to come, and the body belongs to Christ. A shadow is real but not the substance; it points beyond itself. That is why the passage forbids making any such observance a test of standing before God. Notice carefully what the text does not say. It does not command believers to abandon Sabbaths or festivals, and it does not command Sunday keeping either. It removes judgment from the table. The mixed congregation in Colossae was being pressed to treat disputed days as markers of maturity, and Paul refuses that pressure in both directions.
Verses 18 and 19 show where the real danger lies. The next error is self-abasement and angel worship, a religion of impressive humility that does not hold firmly to the Head. Paul ties both errors together: any add-on, whether ascetic rule or calendar rule, that displaces Christ's sufficiency eventually loosens the grip on him. So pastors should be careful here. This text is not a weapon against a believer who keeps Saturday out of conscience, and it is not a license for contempt toward a believer who keeps Sunday. It forbids judging in both directions and leaves the whole question under the lordship of Christ, from whom the body grows.
Where readers disagree about the day
Some careful readers take verse 16 as evidence that the Sabbath never ceased to bind. They argue that the seventh-day rest was woven into creation, before any covenant with Israel, and that Paul is only fending off extra regulations added to it. On that reading, Sunday worship is a tradition of the church rather than a command of God, and a believer who keeps Saturday is simply obeying what was always required. Others read the same verse differently, holding that the Sabbath was a covenant sign given to Israel and fulfilled in Christ, so the specific day is no longer church law. Sunday, on that view, is a wise convention, not a commandment.
A third group tries to hold the pieces together. They see a lasting principle of weekly rest and gathered worship while insisting the particular day is not binding, since Paul explicitly places feast days, new moons and Sabbaths among the shadows. Notice what the text actually does. It says, "Let no one therefore judge you in eating, or in drinking, or with respect to a feast day or a new moon or a Sabbath day" (Colossians 2:16). It forbids judging others on these matters. It never commands a day. Both sides should feel that limit pressing on them, because the verse restrains the one who would police a brother's calendar.
What stays central across these readings is the argument Paul is making. The ordinances against us were wiped out and nailed to the cross, and the powers were stripped and shown openly. Because of that, the calendar cannot be used to question another believer's standing. Verse 17 says the regulations were a shadow, and the body belongs to Christ. So a pastor should be equally careful not to weaponize this passage against a believer who keeps Saturday out of conscience, and not to let it license contempt toward those who keep Sunday. The cross settles our standing. The day does not.
A third group tries to hold the pieces together. They see a lasting principle of weekly rest and gathered worship while insisting the particular day is not binding, since Paul explicitly places feast days, new moons and Sabbaths among the shadows. Notice what the text actually does. It forbids judging others on these matters, and it never commands a day. The verse restrains the one who would police a brother's calendar. What stays central across these readings is the argument Paul is making: the record against us was wiped out and nailed to the cross, the powers were stripped and shown openly, and the regulations were a shadow whose body belongs to Christ. Because of that, no calendar can be used to question another believer's standing at the table.
The shadow and the body: why the day points past itself
Paul does not begin with a rule about calendars. He begins with a cross. Just before these verses he describes a record of debt wiped out, taken out of the way, nailed to the cross, and hostile powers stripped and publicly shamed (2:14–15). Only then does he say, Let no one therefore judge you in eating, or in drinking, or with respect to a feast day or a new moon or a Sabbath day (2:16). The word therefore carries the weight. The freedom he commands rests on something already finished, not on a new set of regulations. The gospel here is a completed work that settles the conscience before any question about days is raised.
Then comes the reason the observances no longer bind: they are a shadow of the things to come; but the body is Christ's (2:17). A shadow is real but derivative. It takes its shape from something solid standing outside it, and it cannot be confused with that solid thing. Paul is not sneering at the feasts and Sabbaths; he is locating them. They pointed forward, and the one they pointed to has arrived. Notice where the emphasis lands: not on a better calendar but on a person. To make the shadow the test of belonging is to treat the pointer as though it were the destination, and that reverses the whole logic of the passage.
Verse 19 finishes the thought with a warning against any religion that does not hold firmly to the Head, from whom the whole body grows. That cuts in every direction. It rebukes the person who keeps Saturday and looks down on the Sunday keeper, and it rebukes the Sunday keeper who treats the Saturday keeper as a project. The text forbids judging both ways. What stays central is Christ, crucified and risen, supplying his body with growth that no observance can manufacture. Days may be kept with gratitude, but they cannot measure acceptance. The finished work frees the conscience, and it also silences contempt.
Holding the day, and the head, in ordinary life
Start with an honest look at what your day is doing in you. Paul writes, "Let no one therefore judge you in eating, or in drinking, or with respect to a feast day or a new moon or a Sabbath day" (Colossians 2:16). The danger runs two ways. You can use a day to measure another believer's standing before God, or you can use it to secure your own, as if careful calendar keeping were the thing that settles your acceptance. The cross already settled it. So ask whether your practice produces quiet gratitude or quiet superiority. If it produces superiority in either direction, the day has quietly taken a place Christ alone should hold.
If you gather on Sunday, receive it as a glad convention and a real gift of rest, not as a law you hand to others and not as a badge you wear. Nothing in this passage commands Sunday, and nothing forbids it. The text calls these observances "a shadow of the things to come; but the body is Christ's" (Colossians 2:17). A shadow is not the substance, but it is not nothing either. Let the day do what a shadow does: point you past itself to Christ. Let it shape your week with worship and rest, and let it leave you gentle toward the brother or sister whose conscience reads the calendar differently.
If you keep Saturday, keep it before the Lord without contempt for those who do not, and do not let anyone rob you of your prize by rules Christ never made. Paul warns against self-abasement and regulations that look humble but do not hold fast to the Head. That is the test for all of us: does this practice attach me more firmly to Christ, or to my own performance? Hold the Head. From him the whole body is supplied and knit together and grows with God's growth. Grace is the ground of every faithful response here, and the passage promises no outcome beyond Christ himself, who is enough for both the one who keeps the day and the one who does not.
Biblical fidelity check
Read closely, Colossians 2:16–17 moves from table to calendar: eating, drinking, a feast, a new moon, a Sabbath day. The Sabbath is named alongside the others, not lifted above them, so the verse resists being turned into a rule about Saturday or Sunday. The word for judge carries a courtroom sense, passing a verdict on someone's standing before God. A shadow is a real but provisional pointer, and the closing line says the solid reality belongs to Christ. The risk here is making the passage say more than it does, either commanding a day or forbidding one.
Evangelical readers genuinely differ. Some keep Saturday because they see the Sabbath rooted in creation and still binding; others see it as an Israelite covenant sign fulfilled in Christ, making Sunday a wise convention rather than law; others hold weekly rest and worship without fixing the day. The text sets its own limit: it forbids judging others over these things and commands no day at all. What stays central is that Christ is the substance, the cross settles our standing, and no calendar may be used to question another believer's place at the table.
Reading Colossians 2:16-17 alongside other passages
These threads are worth following further: the wider argument about shadows and substance in Colossians 1: Paul's Prayer and Christ's Supremacy, the question of how the Old Testament law relates to believers in Colossians 2: Fullness and Freedom in Christ, the discussion of conscience and disputable matters in Colossians 4: Prayer, Speech, and Greetings, and the picture of Christ as head of the body in What Does Colossians 1:23 Mean?.
Frequently asked questions
Does Colossians 2:16 mean the Sabbath command is abolished?
Colossians 2:16 does not say the Sabbath command is abolished; it says no one may judge a believer with respect to a Sabbath day. The verse places such days among shadows that point forward to Christ rather than among the tests by which standing before God is measured. That is a narrower claim than abolition, and readers who conclude the day is fulfilled in Christ and readers who conclude it still stands both have to reckon with what Paul actually forbids here. What the text plainly does is remove human judgment from the question, not legislate a new calendar.
Is worshiping on Sunday a sin or just a church tradition?
Worshiping on Sunday is not made a sin by Colossians 2:16–17, and the passage does not make it a law either. Paul names festivals, new moons, and Sabbaths as shadows and refuses to let anyone judge over them, which leaves the day itself outside the courtroom he is describing. Sunday gathering is a long-standing practice of the churches rather than a command issued in this text. A believer who keeps Sunday out of conviction and a believer who keeps Saturday out of conviction are both told here not to despise or judge the other.
Can I be judged by other Christians for which day I rest and worship?
Colossians 2:16 answers directly: let no one judge you in eating, in drinking, or with respect to a feast day, a new moon, or a Sabbath day. The command runs against the one doing the judging, so no fellow believer has been given authority to rule on your calendar. That cuts in both directions, since the same verse keeps you from turning your own practice into a verdict on someone else. Rest and worship are to be worked out before the Lord, not settled by pressure from a peer.