Job 35: Elihu on Job's Righteousness and God's Silence

Short answer: Elihu answers Job by arguing that human righteousness or sin does not affect God, and that pride prevents people from seeking their Maker. He concludes that Job speaks empty words without knowledge.

What Job 35 says

Elihu opens his third speech by directly addressing Job's claim that his righteousness exceeds God's, as stated in verse 2. He repeats Job's question from verse 3 about what advantage there is in not sinning. Elihu then invites Job and his companions to look at the skies in verse 5, using the height of the heavens to illustrate God's transcendence. The argument is that if Job has sinned, it does not harm God, and if he is righteous, it does not benefit God, as verses 6 and 7 make clear. This section sets up the central thesis that God is not dependent on human moral performance.

In verses 8 through 11, Elihu shifts to the human plane. He acknowledges that wickedness hurts other people and righteousness can profit a fellow human. Yet he observes that when people cry out under oppression, they do not ask where God their Maker is, the one who gives songs in the night. Elihu contrasts this with the animals, saying God teaches humans more than the beasts and makes them wiser than the birds. The point is that suffering often drives people to cry for relief rather than to seek the God who is the source of wisdom and song. This is a subtle critique of Job's focus on vindication rather than on God himself.

Verses 12 through 14 address the problem of unanswered prayer. Elihu says that people cry out but no one answers because of the pride of evil men. He asserts that God will not hear an empty cry, nor will the Almighty regard it. Then he applies this to Job directly: how much less will God listen when Job says he does not see him. Elihu insists that the cause is before God and that Job must wait for him. This section turns the argument toward Job's own words, suggesting that his complaint about God's silence is itself a mark of pride and a failure to wait rightly.

The final two verses, 15 and 16, bring Elihu's speech to a close. He says that because God has not visited in anger or greatly regarded arrogance, Job opens his mouth with empty talk and multiplies words without knowledge. This is a sharp conclusion. Elihu charges Job with speaking beyond what he knows. The chapter ends without a direct response from Job, leaving Elihu's critique hanging. The movement of the chapter is from a general principle about God's transcendence, to a human observation about prayer, to a specific accusation against Job, and finally to a verdict on Job's speech.

Verses that carry the chapter

• ““Do you think this to be your right, or do you say, ‘My righteousness is more than God’s,’” (Job 35:2) — This verse frames the entire chapter by quoting Job's implied claim that his righteousness is greater than God's. It sets the terms of the debate.
• “If you are righteous, what do you give him? Or what does he receive from your hand?” (Job 35:7) — This verse asks what a person gives to God or what God receives from human hands, highlighting the central argument that God is not enriched by our righteousness.
• “But no one says, ‘Where is God my Maker, who gives songs in the night,” (Job 35:10) — This verse introduces the poignant image of God as the Maker who gives songs in the night, a rare note of hope in the midst of suffering.
• “Therefore Job opens his mouth with empty talk, and he multiplies words without knowledge.”” (Job 35:16) — This verse delivers Elihu's final verdict that Job speaks empty words without knowledge, summarizing his critique of Job's complaints.

Gospel connection

Elihu's argument that human sin and righteousness do not affect God finds its deepest resolution in the gospel. The Bible consistently presents God as transcendent and self-sufficient, yet it also reveals that God chose to enter human history in Christ. In Jesus, God did not remain distant from human sin and suffering. Instead, Christ bore the consequences of sin on the cross, satisfying divine justice and demonstrating that our actions do matter to God, not because he needs us, but because he loves us. The songs in the night that Elihu mentions point forward to the hope we have in Christ, who gives peace and joy even in darkness. Where Elihu could only accuse and point to God's greatness, the gospel shows God's greatness expressed in self-giving love. The book of Job ultimately points to a mediator, and the New Testament identifies that mediator as Jesus, who answers the problem of innocent suffering through his own suffering and resurrection.

Application

This chapter invites us to examine our own expectations of God. Do we serve him for what we get, or do we love him for who he is? Elihu's words challenge the transactional faith that says, if I am good, God owes me a comfortable life. Instead, we are called to trust God even when we do not see his hand, to wait for him rather than demand immediate answers. The image of God as the one who gives songs in the night encourages us to seek him in our darkest hours, not just for relief, but for himself. Practically, this means examining our prayers: are they only cries for help, or do they include a longing for the God who made us? It also means humbling ourselves when we are tempted to accuse God of unfairness. Like Job, we may not understand our suffering, but we can choose to speak with reverence rather than empty words. The chapter calls us to a quiet trust that God is God, and we are not.

Biblical fidelity check

This chapter does not claim that Elihu's words are the final word from God. In fact, the book of Job later shows that God speaks directly and does not fully endorse Elihu's assessment. The text does not say that Job was actually guilty of the pride Elihu accuses him of, nor does it claim that all suffering is a result of pride. Elihu speaks from his own perspective, and the chapter is silent on whether his conclusions about Job's heart are correct. It also does not explain why God gives songs in the night or why some prayers go unanswered. The chapter does not present a complete theology of suffering; it is one human voice in a larger dialogue. Readers should be careful not to treat Elihu's words as absolute truth, but as part of the book's exploration of these deep questions.

Questions for study

1. What does Elihu accuse Job of claiming in verse 2, and how does that set up his argument?
2. According to verses 6 and 7, what effect does human sin or righteousness have on God? How does that challenge or comfort you?
3. In verse 10, Elihu mentions God as the one who gives songs in the night. What might that mean for someone in deep suffering?
4. Why does Elihu say in verse 12 that people cry out but no one answers? What does he identify as the reason?
5. How does Elihu's final charge in verse 16 summarize his view of Job's words? Do you think it is fair? Why or why not?

Keep reading

Related studies: Job 1 Bible Study, Job 10 Bible Study, Job 11 Bible Study, Job 12 Bible Study.

Subscribe for new Bible studies or support this work.

FAQ

Who is Elihu and why is he speaking?

Elihu is a younger man who has been listening to Job and his three friends. He speaks up because he is angry that Job justifies himself rather than God, and that the friends have failed to answer Job adequately.

What is the main point of Job 35?

The main point is that human righteousness or sin does not affect God's own well-being, and that people often cry out in suffering without truly seeking God. Elihu concludes that Job speaks empty words without knowledge.

Does God agree with Elihu's assessment of Job?

The book of Job does not explicitly say God agrees with Elihu. Later, God speaks to Job directly and does not repeat Elihu's accusations, suggesting that Elihu's words are not the final or complete truth about Job's situation.