Why Jesus Says to Fast in Secret (Matthew 6:16–18)

Short answer: Matthew 6:16–18 shows Jesus expects fasting but rejects performative piety. He commands secrecy, contrasting temporary human applause with eternal divine reward. Fasting here is worship stripped of audience, done for God alone. The passage redefines spiritual discipline as relationship, not religious impression.

Fasting in the context of Jesus' sermon

In Matthew 6:16–18, Jesus addresses fasting as part of his broader teaching in the Sermon on the Mount. This sermon outlines the ethics of God’s kingdom for his disciples, emphasizing a heart-oriented devotion to God rather than outward displays of piety. Jesus assumes fasting is a normal spiritual practice but critiques its misuse by hypocrites who fast for human approval. His teaching follows a pattern seen earlier in the chapter, where he exposes the emptiness of hypocritical acts of righteousness, such as giving and praying. Here, fasting becomes the third example of how not to practice piety.

The immediate context of this passage is crucial. Jesus has just taught his disciples how to pray, including the Lord’s Prayer, which highlights forgiveness as a central theme. Forgiveness connects to fasting because fasting often expresses repentance and dependence on God. Jesus then transitions into warnings about divided loyalty, contrasting earthly treasures with eternal ones. The “reward” language in 6:16–18 flows naturally into the treasure metaphor of 6:19–20, showing that fasting, like storing treasures, should focus on eternal realities rather than temporary human approval.

Jesus’ teaching on fasting is practical and countercultural. He warns against disfiguring one’s face to appear pious, a common practice among hypocrites seeking public admiration. Instead, he instructs his disciples to fast discreetly, anointing their heads and washing their faces so their fasting is unseen by others but known to God. This secrecy ensures the focus remains on God, not on human recognition. The reward comes from God, who sees what is done in secret, reinforcing the idea that true piety is about a relationship with God, not outward performance.

How not to fast when seeking God

Jesus warns against fasting for human applause (Matthew 6:16). Religious performers in his day would deliberately look haggard, disfiguring their faces, to advertise their spiritual discipline. The phrase suggests theatrical exaggeration, like actors smearing dirt for effect. Their goal was visibility: “that they may be seen by men.” Jesus bluntly says such showmanship earns exactly what it seeks, human admiration, and nothing more. The problem isn't fasting itself but turning it into religious theater. When spiritual practices become performance art, the audience shifts from God to people. Applause replaces true reward.

Instead, Jesus instructs his followers to maintain normal appearances while fasting (Matthew 6:17). “Anoint your head and wash your face” means don't neglect basic grooming. Oil and water were standard hygiene, not luxuries. The command counters the assumption that fasting requires visible misery. Jesus cares about the heart's posture, not outward signals. This isn't hiding faith but refusing to use piety as a status marker. Fasting isn't diminished by looking ordinary; its power comes from honest seeking, not dramatic displays. The difference lies in who you're trying to impress.

The true reward comes from God alone (Matthew 6:18). Jesus highlights the Father as the one “who sees in secret.” This doesn't mean God only notices hidden acts but that he values motives over visibility. Unlike human spectators, God isn't fooled by religious costumes. The reward isn't material but relational, being known and affirmed by him. Jesus' teaching dismantles the idea that spiritual intensity must look dramatic. Fasting is about communion, not compensation. When done rightly, it nurtures dependence on God rather than courting admiration. The Father’s recognition far outweighs any human applause.

Fasting as a private act before God

Jesus assumes his followers will fast but warns against turning it into a public performance. He criticizes hypocrites who disfigure their faces to make their fasting obvious. Their goal is to gain admiration from others, and Jesus says they succeed, they receive the human approval they seek. But that’s all they get. Their reward is temporary and shallow because it relies on the fleeting opinions of people rather than the eternal perspective of God. Fasting, for Jesus, is not about impressing others but about humbling oneself before God in secret, where only he sees and responds.

Jesus instructs his followers to fast differently: anoint your head and wash your face so no one knows you’re fasting. This isn’t about hiding piety but redirecting focus. The goal is intimacy with God, not recognition from others. When fasting is done in secret, it becomes a genuine act of devotion rather than a performance for applause. Jesus promises that God, who sees in secret, will reward such fasting. This reward isn’t defined here but is connected to the eternal treasures mentioned in the following verses, pointing to something far greater than human approval.

This teaching on fasting fits within Jesus’ broader message about priorities. It follows his call to forgive others (6:14–15) and precedes his warning against storing up earthly treasures (6:19–20). Fasting is linked to repentance and forgiveness, as it often expresses sorrow for sin and dependence on God’s mercy. It’s also an investment in eternal realities, like forgiveness and heavenly treasures, rather than temporary gains. By fasting in secret, believers align themselves with God’s values, seeking his approval over human praise and storing up lasting rewards in heaven.

Jesus corrects how religious people misuse fasting

Jesus targets hypocrisy, not fasting itself. His “when you fast” assumes some will fast but rebukes performative religion. Hypocrites deliberately make themselves look miserable to gain admiration. Their reward is exactly what they wanted, human applause, but nothing from God. Jesus doesn't question fasting's value but its misuse. The issue isn't whether to fast but why. This matches his earlier teaching on giving and prayer (6:1–15), where motives matter more than mechanics. Fasting, like those acts, must serve communion with God, not social reputation.

The alternative isn't abandoning fasting but redirecting it. “Anoint your head and wash your face” means live normally, no signaling. This isn't a ban on corporate fasts (Acts 13:2–3) but on self-display. God sees secret acts, so secrecy ensures the reward comes from him alone. Unlike hypocrites who trade spirituality for status, disciples trade visibility for intimacy. Jesus doesn't specify fast frequency or duration; the text regulates attitude, not schedule. The non-negotiable is that fasting must be God-centered, not self-promoting.

Two limits guard against misreading. First, secrecy isn't magic, hiding deeds doesn't force God's hand, as 6:18's “will reward you” parallels 6:6's: will reward openly. Second, fasting isn't meritorious; the Father's care precedes human effort (6:8, 6:32). Some Christians fast regularly as disciplined hunger for God; others reserve it for repentance or crisis. Both can obey Jesus by rejecting performative religion. What unites them is seeking God himself, not using spiritual practices as leverage. The passage makes fasting about relationship, not transaction.

Jesus redefines fasting as secret fellowship with the Father

Jesus contrasts two ways to fast in 6:16–18. Hypocrites disfigure their faces to win human applause, which becomes their only reward. True fasting happens secretly before the Father who sees in hidden places. This isn’t about hiding a spiritual practice in shame but redirecting its audience from spectators to God. Jesus assumes his followers will fast, but reshapes it as communion rather than performance. His own 40-day wilderness fast modeled this – no audience, just obedience. The Father who noticed Jesus’ secret resistance to temptation now sees our hidden acts of dependence too.

Fasting under the gospel remembers Christ as the true bridegroom who made old rituals unnecessary (Mark 2:19–20). We don’t fast to summon God’s presence but because we miss Christ’s physical presence until his return. It’s a temporary ache, not a bargaining tool. Jesus warns against treating fasting as a lever to force answered prayer (6:16) or earn spiritual status. The Father’s reward comes not because we fasted well but because he sees us in Christ. Our small denials echo Jesus’ ultimate self-denial, now fulfilled in his victory over temptation.

The resurrected Christ proves the Father rewards secret obedience. Jesus’ hidden fasting in the desert led to public vindication at his resurrection. Our small fasts now participate in that pattern – unseen today but guaranteed future glory. This passage isn’t about techniques but identity: we fast as children trusting their Father’s attention, not employees earning a wage. The same Father who saw Jesus’ secret obedience sees ours, not because we’re impressive but because we’re in his Son. Fasting becomes gospel-shaped when it flows from Christ’s finished work, not toward it.

Fasting as a quiet act of trust

In Matthew 6:16–18, Jesus warns his followers not to fast like the hypocrites, who disfigure their faces to draw attention to their piety. This isn’t just about avoiding theatrics; it’s about the heart behind the practice. Fasting isn’t a performance for others, nor is it a tool to manipulate God. Instead, it’s a quiet act of trust, a way to express dependence on God without seeking applause. Jesus calls us to fast in a way that maintains normal hygiene and appearance, showing that the focus isn’t on outward displays but on the private relationship between us and our Father in heaven.

Jesus emphasizes that fasting finds its meaning in God’s presence, not in human recognition. When he says, ‘your Father, who sees in secret, will reward you’ (Matthew 6:18), he reminds us that God values sincerity over spectacle. This doesn’t mean fasting guarantees specific outcomes or answered prayers. Rather, it’s about aligning our hearts with God’s will, seeking him with humility and honesty. The reward isn’t material or transactional; it’s the deepening of our relationship with God, who sees and honors our genuine pursuit of him.

Fasting flows from grace, not from a desire to earn God’s favor. Earlier in Matthew 6, Jesus connects forgiveness with forgiving others (6:14–15), grounding spiritual practices in the reality of God’s mercy. When we fast, we do so as forgiven people, not to secure forgiveness but to respond to it. This discipline isn’t about self-punishment or proving our spirituality. It’s a way to focus our hearts on God, acknowledging our need for him and celebrating his grace. In ordinary life, fasting becomes a practical expression of faith, a quiet reminder that our true treasure is in heaven (6:20), not in earthly recognition or reward.

Biblical fidelity check

In Matthew 6:16–18, Jesus critiques hypocrites who fast ostentatiously, disfiguring their faces to gain public admiration. He contrasts this with private fasting, where one maintains normal appearance to avoid drawing attention. The phrase “disfigure their faces” refers to deliberate dishevelment, a cultural signal of fasting. Jesus instructs his followers to “anoint your head and wash your face,” meaning they should appear ordinary, not signaling their spiritual practice to others. The focus is on God as the true audience: “Your Father who sees in secret will reward you.” Reward here refers to divine recognition, not material gain, emphasizing fasting’s purpose as Godward, not human-centered.

Evangelicals debate whether Jesus' “when you fast” assumes fasting as an ongoing obligation or simply addresses its existing practice. Some view fasting as primarily for repentance or crisis moments (Joel 2:12), while others see it as a regular spiritual discipline. The text doesn’t prescribe frequency but establishes core principles: fasting should be private and God-focused. Disagreements about its role persist, but the central point remains clear: fasting is not for public display but for intimate communion with God. Its value lies in sincerity and secrecy, not in external recognition or ritual observance.

Where Matthew 6:16-18 connects to the rest of Scripture

For more on spiritual disciplines, see Jesus Denounces Hypocrisy in Matthew 23 on prayer, Matthew 1: Genealogy and Birth of Jesus on giving, or Matthew 10: Jesus Sends the Twelve with Authority on resisting hypocrisy. Explore Matthew 12: Lord of the Sabbath and Sign of Jonah for Jesus’ broader sermon.

Frequently asked questions

Does Jesus command all Christians to fast?

Jesus says “when you fast” (6:16), assuming the practice without commanding it. The focus is motive, not mandate. He critiques misuse, not the act itself. Early Christians fasted (Acts 13:2), but Paul later treats it as voluntary (1 Corinthians 7:5).

What's the difference between biblical fasting and hunger strikes?

Biblical fasting seeks God, not social change. It’s worship, withholding food to focus on him, unlike protests that coerce outcomes. Jesus fasted to resist temptation (Matthew 4:2) and prepare for ministry, modeling dependence, not demands.

Why does God reward something done in secret?

Secret fasting proves sincerity. Public piety often plays to crowds (6:16), but God values undivided hearts. Reward comes not because we hide good deeds but because hiddenness purifies motives. The Father sees what no one else does (6:18).

Subscribe for more Scripture-centered studies.

Support Sermon Academy.

Previous
Previous

Why Jesus said true worship isn't about location

Next
Next

Why God Clothed Adam and Eve After Their Sin in Genesis 3:21